Innovation and Inspiration: The Campaign for Kansas University

Breaking Your News Bubble

This guide offers methods and resources to critically evaluate the news you consume.

Ask a Librarian

Either JavaScript is disabled in your browser or our chat service is unavailable. For chat hours see Hale Library's calendar. If you like, you can leave us a message at 785-532-3014 or e-mail your question to <a "mailto:libhelp@k-state.edu"=""> libhelp@k-state.edu.

Librarian

Sara K. Kearns's picture
Sara K. Kearns
Contact:
skearns@k-state.edu
203 Hale Library

Make an appointment
Calendar

Librarian

Daniel Ireton's picture
Daniel Ireton
Contact:
Associate Professor
Academic Services Librarian
208 Hale Library
dli6873@k-state.edu
785-532-7436

Welcome!

Welcome to the Libraries' Breaking Your News Bubble Guide! This guide is designed to help you learn to

  • be critical and thoughtful when reading and sharing news
  • diversify your news sources

Join us for an evaluation of your current media diet, and come away with a menu for well-balanced media consumption.

If you would like more information don't hesitate to Ask A Librarian for help any time during the Libraries' service hours.

Each link in this guide opens in a new tab.

In the following video librarians Sara K. Kearns and Daniel Ireton describe the news bubble and how to critically evaluate and diversify your news.

What is a Bubble?

What is a bubble? Your bubble is your comfortable environment. In a news bubble you encounter content that interests you from perspectives that agree with yours.

Algorithms (mathematical formulas) on the internet collect our personal information (including where we go, how we get there, what we like, etc.) to filter news so we see what we want to see, even without intentionally doing so. This places us in a filter bubble.

Unlike picking up the hard copy of the daily paper in the yard, the virtual environment is constantly evolving and seeking our approval. Such online personalization is convenient when we're shopping on Amazon ("customers who bought this item also bought") or looking for our next Netflix binge ("because you watched") but can be divisive and polarizing when it comes to our news.

Guide to Better News Habits

lego faces wonder, scared, surprised, and laughing

Question the things that you read and hear about. Pick one thing every day that makes you feel good or bad. Something that claims to present the entire story, but maybe doesn’t.

 

Develop a list of trusted sources – this is a great way to check what is posted on social media. If Forbes or the Wall Street Journal is reporting from a different perspective than something your friend posted, consider that carefully. Watch out for things like:

  1. A politician you’re already disposed against says something you disagree with.
  2. An unbelievable scientific breakthrough is announced.
  3. A lot of people are outraged over someone’s words on social media

 

 

Silhouette of a bear reading

Read it! A headline can be very misleading, occasionally purposely so. Don’t allow yourself to confirm or deny what’s actually being reported without reading the entire article. Also, in some cases be aware that retractions can be issued – when a big story breaks, that may not be the last word.

 

 

Engage. Find ways to talk to those posting bad information or spurious sources – this isn’t easy, and close to impossible on social media.

 

  • Don’t assume that because another person posts/talks/shares a lot that they are better informed than you.
  • Ask questions and give them the opportunity to answer.
  • Don’t post angry.
  • Offer information from sources you’ve found that may contradict, but make certain that mutual understanding is your goal.

 

You aren’t trying to win an argument, you’re trying to build a community of better informed citizens.

Image credits: Lego emotions by TMD, bear reading by Alexander Krasnov